Nelson Law Group
Employment Law Attorneys
SF Bay Area : 415-689-6590
Toll Free : 866-290-0424

Must be able to hire and fire to be considered a "supervisor", says U.S. Supreme Court

Resolving long-standing confusion over how to determine who is a supervisor under Title VII, the Court adopted the more stringent, pro-employer standard that people must have authority to take adverse employment actions (e.g., hiring, firing, demotions, etc.) to be considered supervisors. The alternative standard, followed by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (and various courts), was that supervisors only needed to be able to significantly influence co-workers' employment. Whether someone is considered a supervisor is particularly important for harassment cases brought under Title VII, the federal anti-discrimination law, as different rules apply to harassment committed by supervisors, as opposed to just co-workers. Employers must have actually been negligent in allowing co-worker harassment to be liable for it, whereas they are automatically liable for supervisor harassment, barring an affirmative defense. The Court issued its ruling in Vance v. Ball State University, in which a cafeteria employee claimed she had been harassed by a co-worker who "glared at" and "intimidated" her. Although Vance is a Supreme Court ruling, it should not impact most harassment cases in California, which are generally brought under the state's anti-discrimination law, the Fair Employment and Housing Act ("FEHA"). FEHA specifically defines supervisors in the less-stringent way advocated by the EEOC. 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information


Representing both employers and employees makes me a better lawyer, because I know how the other side thinks.

Read More


I can provide the same level of service as a large law firm, but more efficiently and at a lower cost.

Read More

How Can We Help ?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Keep In Touch

Nelson Law Group
345 West Portal Avenue
Suite 110
San Francisco, California 94127

Toll Free: 866-290-0424
Phone: 415-689-6590
Fax: 415-592-8671
Map & Directions
San Francisco Law Office Map