Nelson Law Group
Employment Law Attorneys
SF Bay Area : 415-689-6590
Toll Free : 866-290-0424

"He said, (s)he said" evidence good enough to get discrimination cases to trial

Many people who suspect they have been wrongfully terminated think they need "smoking gun" evidence to even have a chance in court. Not so, says a recent California appellate court case. 

In Nigro v. Sears, Roebuck and Co., the court ruled that just about any kind of evidence of discrimination will enable a case to proceed to trial, even if it is just the "self-serving" recollection of a biased plaintiff. The plaintiff in Nigro submitted a declaration (i.e., his own sworn statement) saying that he recalled his boss admitting that Sears would not accommodate the plaintiff's disability. There were no incriminating emails or other documentary evidence; it was just the plaintiff's word against the boss. The trial court initially disregarded the plaintiff's declaration as biased and dismissed the case. But the appellate court reversed, holding that even cases supported only by self-serving declarations deserve to be decided by juries. Nigro confirms that discrimination cases supported by sufficient evidence should survive summary judgment and be allowed to proceed to trial, regardless what kind of evidence it is. 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information


Representing both employers and employees makes me a better lawyer, because I know how the other side thinks.

Read More


I can provide the same level of service as a large law firm, but more efficiently and at a lower cost.

Read More

How Can We Help ?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Keep In Touch

Nelson Law Group
345 West Portal Avenue
Suite 110
San Francisco, California 94127

Toll Free: 866-290-0424
Phone: 415-689-6590
Fax: 415-592-8671
Map & Directions
San Francisco Law Office Map